The number of vessels involved in marine accidents is increasing every year, with fishing vessel accidents accounting for 80% of all vessel accidents. Small fishing vessels refer to fishing vessels with a gross tonnage of fewer than 10 tons, and accidents involving small fishing vessels account for 71% of all fishing vessel accidents (Korea Maritime Safety Tribunal, 2021; Ministry of Oceans and Fisheries, 2020). Small fishing vessels are significantly affected even by small waves, leading to accidents, such as capsizing or sinking.
Meanwhile, domestic small fishing vessels are mainly built in small or medium-sized shipyards. Accordingly, they are built based on an existing mother vessel, relying on experience rather than using systematic procedures. Under this circumstance, it is difficult to conduct studies on hull forms to increase the efficiency of resistance performance and motion performance for small fishing vessels. Recently, more studies have been conducted on fishing vessels. However, most of these studies were focused on the operability, convenience, and speed of fishing vessels (Yu et al., 2010; Park et al., 2016a; Seok et al., 2018). In the case of small fishing vessels, the position of the transverse metacentric height changes frequently based on the fishing operation environment, affecting vessel stability, which is closely related to the roll motion of the vessel. Methods for analyzing the stability include numerical analysis, computational fluid dynamics analysis, experiments, and real ship tests. Im and Lee (2021) utilized computational fluid dynamics to analyze the motion response characteristics of small fishing vessels in regular waves based on the size of the fishing vessel and verified that the maximum value of the motion response moves to the long-wavelength region as the vessel speed increases in bow sea conditions, regardless of the size of the vessel. An experimental study on the motion response characteristics of small fishing vessels wavesteepness inclines in beam sea conditions verified that if only the resistance characteristics are considered for the chine line shape in the design of the hull of the vessel, the motion performance of the vessel can be degraded when it is damaged. In addition, it was confirmed that the position of the chine line shape significantly impacts vessel motion (Park et al., 2011). An analysis of seakeeping performance using multi-purpose fishing training vessels analyzed the performance of tasks under each sea condition and presented guidelines on adjusting the wave encounter angle an avoidance or changing the course of the vessel based on the sea condition (Ryu et al., 2019). The roll motion characteristics of a small fishing vessel were analyzed based on the change in the wave encounter angle and speed of the small fishing vessel. Although the roll motion response rapidly increased in a beam sea or stern sea, a real ship test verified that the motion period does not change much because of the wave direction (Kang et al., 2007). The hull response characteristics of a stern-type trawler were measured according to wavesteepnes and wave direction via a real ship test when the trawler was drifting, sailing, and trawling. When the trawler was drifting, the maximum and significant values of the angle of roll motion increased as the wave height increased. However, both the maximum and significant values of the angle of pitch motion decreased (Park et al., 2016b).
In this study, we conduct a tank test experiment by simulating the drifting state of three small fishing vessels. First, we analyze the roll and pitch motion characteristics of these vessels in regular waves with uniform wave steepness. Then, we compare the characteristics of each fishing vessel with each other to present foundational data for the development of fishing vessels in terms of seakeeping performance. In addition, we analyze the roll and pitch motion characteristics of a 7-ton fishing vessel in a bow sea and a stern sea based on wave steepness to verify whether these characteristics increase linearly.
>
Description of Setup and Model
Considering small fishing vessels account for 71% of recent fishing vessel accidents, we selected three sizes of fishing vessels under 10 tons, including a 3-ton (2.99), 7-ton (7.93), and 10-ton (9.77) class vessels, to analyze the response characteristics of small fishing vessels in regular waves (Im and Lee, 2021).
The model experiment was conducted in the ocean engineering basin with a dimension of 28 × 22 × 2 m at the Research Institute of Medium and Small Shipbuilding (RIMS). The wave maker consisted of a system with a total length of 22.0 m, including 40 segments, a height of 1.0 m, and a width of 0.4 m. Moreover, wave absorber was installed on the opposite side of the wave maker to absorb incoming waves and prevent wave reflections at the boundary of the wave basin and to achieve interaction between the floating object and the wave by adjusting the infinite range of the fluid. The fishing vessel was located in the center of the basin, as shown in
The following wave encounter angles (
The height of the waves was measured using a wire resistance-type wave probe. The wave height signal was converted into a voltage and sent to the data acquisition board in the computer. All data from the wave probe was measured at a sampling rate of 20 Hz. The motion characteristics of the fishing vessel were measured using alternating current (AC) electromagnetic-type motion measurement equipment, with data transmitted to a PC via radio frequency (RF) wireless communication. The motion measurement equipment can measure six degrees of freedom, but only heave, roll, and pitch motions were measured in this study.
For regular wave validation, eight regular waves with the same wave steepness and different wave periods and four regular waves with the same period and different wave steepness were generated in the wave tank with a depth of 2 m. The physical wave maker signal was converted into a voltage and sent to the data acquisition board, ensuring excellent repeatability of the experiment. The measurement time was set to less than or equal to 40 s to avoid the effect of reflected waves on the experimental results. At least 30 wave periods were generated for each wave, with 9–11 wave periods in a normal state selected.
>
Analysis of Motion in Regular Waves with the Same Wave Steepness
>
Analysis of Motion in Regular Waves with Different Wave Steepness
The size of the roll and pitch motions increased as the wave steepness increased in both a bow sea (
In this study, we conducted wave tank tests on three small fishing vessels by simulating drifting conditions. The characteristics of the roll and pitch motions were analyzed in regular waves with the same wave steepness. We analyzed the seakeeping performances by comparing the characteristics of each vessel. We verified whether the roll and pitch motion characteristics increased linearly and drew the following conclusions by analyzing the roll and pitch motion characteristics of a 7-ton class fishing vessel according to the wave steepness in a bow sea and stern sea. The largest heave motions occur when λ/D = 2.36 in a beam sea when 3-ton, 7-ton, and 10-ton class fishing vessels were drifting. Therefore, such a fishing vessel should change its direction towards the bow sea or stern sea direction. Large roll motions also occur when λ/D = 2.36 in a beam sea. In the case of the 10-ton class fishing vessel, huge roll motion characteristics are exhibited at λ/D = 4.72. Therefore, 10-ton class fishing vessels should avoid a beam sea when drifting. The largest pitch motions occur in a head sea and a following sea. As the wavelength is longer than the size of the vessel, similar characteristics are exhibited. Fishing vessels should turn in a direction other than a beam sea, which generates large roll motions because roll motions are larger than pitch motions in all fishing vessels. We checked the roll and pitch motion characteristics by varying the wave steepness while keeping the wave period the same in a bow sea and stern sea. Considering the characteristics increased linearly, we can substitute the wave height to obtain the motion characteristics of the wave height.
In the future, we plan to experimentally analyze the change in the motion characteristics based on the change in the center of gravity through regular and irregular waves to use the study findings as foundation data for improving the stability of fishing vessels.